"Eco-Safe" Cultivars of Invasive Plants?

"Eco-Safe" Cultivars of Invasive Plants?

Posted by KK on Jun 13th 2024

By KK

Remember when gardening was like everything else--when you could just do something without making a choice to be "responsible"?  We have a whole new world to which we're adjusting, and it's a good thing, but a lot more complicated.  Fortunately, as humans we have the skills to navigate this new terrain, incorporating the knowledge so readily available at our fingertips whenever we desire.  But whose information do we use, and how do we evaluate the validity?  Yes, even in gardening there is truth, and then another truth. As such, this blog was inspired by my desire to plant a beautiful, long-blooming plant that would not add to the burden of invasive species, so I began my search.  Was there an "eco-safe" butterfly bush? As it turns out, there's no simple answer to that question, for butterfly bushes or any other plant.  

Flower cluster of blue butterfly bush showing each flower with tiny orange center
Butterfly bushes offer long-blooming color, heat and drought tolerance, and deer resistance--and they can seed like crazy.

Plant Patents are Gold for Gardeners

In general, "eco-safe" varieties have an altered ability to reproduce.  They have been tested for some number of years (usually by the breeder) to evaluate that ability, as well as the stability of the prominent ornamental features of the plant. This isn't done out of the goodness of anyone's heart in concern for environmental safety (entirely). Rather, it's all part of the patent process, which enables breeders to protect their invention, thus preserving profits for themselves for a prescribed time. 


You can look up a cultivar's patent online.  Google Patents and Justia Patents are two sites you can use to search--you can enter the botanical and cultivar name, or sometimes just the common name may bring it up.  Note that many plants have an original (unfamiliar) patented name AND a subsequent trade name that is used once the plant goes to market, and you may not find the trade name on those sites. That makes it a little harder, but your best bet is googling the plant name with addition of the word "patent".  For instance, for a certain winterberry holly, Ilex 'Little Goblin' is the trade name, but the actual patented name is 'NCIV1.'


So what might that patent information tell you? Depending on whether it is an annual, perennial, shrub, etc., a great deal:


  • Features that make this cultivar distinct from similar varieties, whether it be flower color, habit, tolerance of certain growing conditions, etc. 

  • Basic features of the plant in great detail--size, shape, growth rate--better than any plant description you'll ever find, primarily since you're seeing ALL the information, not just the the traits the marketers want you to focus on

  • Leaf color and texture in all seasons

  • Flower fragrance, persistence, and blooming season

  • Disease resistance and cold hardiness

  • If the plant is male or female, requires a pollinator, and other reproductive traits. That information is rarely provide by garden centers or found on plant tags. 

  • Description of the root system, which can be quite valuable to know and which you'll never be told

  • Where and how long the plant was grown to establish these qualities, and under what conditions (field, greenhouse, etc.)

  • The plant's lineage--just like for a pedigreed dog. This will tell you whether the plant is a natural cross or hybrid selection or genetically modified. (A natural cross can be induced by a human moving the pollen--that is NOT a genetically modified plant).


So as you can see, an enormous amount can be gleaned from patent info!  For "eco-safe" cultivars, you'll mostly be concerned about the reproductive traits, for which there is often a section called just that. If not, you want to look under the flower description at "reproductive organs" and "seeds and fruit," and note the amount of pollen and seed produced. Yes, there will be some botanical language to slog through, but we can simplify that.

    Plant Reproduction Basics and Sterility

    As mentioned, "eco-safe" generally means that the plant's reproduction is hampered in some way, resulting in reduced fertility.  So how is this accomplished? A little basic botany is required here.


    In typical garden flowers, the pollen from the stamen is transferred to the stigma, thus initiating reproduction if fertilization occurs. Therefore, in plants with altered fertility, male parts (anthers/stamens--produce pollen) or female parts (pistil, stigma, style, & ovary--produce seed) are essentially dysfunctional in some fashion. This can be one or the other, or both. You may see these conditions referred to as male sterile, female sterile, or completely/fully sterile, respectively.


    A common acceptable condition that allows a cultivar of a regulated invasive plant to be sold is that the plant produce less than 2% viable seed. This is the case in Oregon, where Buddleia davidii is classed as invasive, but cultivars with such reduced fertility are permitted for sale. Interestingly, some of these are not allowed to be sold as "butterfly bush," but must be labelled "summer lilac" or "nectar bush," I assume to reduce confusion for consumers.  Or, possibly to increase sales to those who don't want to plant something they know is invasive?  Sorry, I wasn't at that meeting, but I imagine some horticultural industry lobbyists and conservationists were.


      butterfly bush growing wild and blooming, between concrete sidewalk and wall with graffiti on wall
      Wild buddleia happily growing, blooming, and setting seed in a crack in concrete--one reason why we don't need this escaping from our gardens.

      Why does it matter?

      Ok, so here's the important part that you don't see on your "nectar bush" label.  If the plant fertility is reduced, then what's the problem?  That depends on your point of view, so I'll leave the decision up to you, with these considerations:


      • Butterfly bushes are copious producers of seed. It is estimated that ONE butterfly bush can produce up to 3 MILLION seeds in a season, and 2% of that is 60,000. That's still a LOT of seed. Its long-distance dispersal by wind is highly efficient, and it germinates and grows easily in poor, minimal soil and disturbed areas--like cracks in sidewalks, construction areas, and vacant lots.
      • Cultivars that are only female sterile still produce viable pollen that can fertilize wild populations, and male sterile plants can potentially be fertilized by pollen from wild populations.  In time, especially with plants like Buddleia that rely heavily on cross-pollination, that can lead to passing on traits of the cultivars that may further increase the survivability of the plants in the wild. 
      • It is also possible that due to gene transfer in this way, over time fertility could be restored to these "safe" varieties. Since "safe" varieties were developed and selected in relatively few years and did not exist before, no one knows how quickly this could occur. This has already been documented in other supposedly sterile cultivars of other species, such as Hibiscus syriacus (Rose of Sharon, Althea). Particularly in those that favor cross-pollination, one wonders whether lack of adequate exposure to other varieties during the development and testing period may simply mask the actual reproductive abilities of the plant.
      • Even one of the breeders of such plants does not completely discount the chance of seed production: this "does not preclude the possibility that seed set may be observed on rare occasions.”


      Armed with this knowledge, you can make your choice.  Below are some cultivars stated as having reduced or absent fertility.  We would certainly recommend these over other Buddleia cultivars that lack this feature. And of course, timely deadheading will remove seeds before they are able to form. Note that there is only one native butterfly that uses Buddleia davidii as a food source for caterpillars, so we should still look to include native plants such as itea, clethra, aronia, fothergilla, and others. Now you know how to look them up if they're patented, get the real skinny, and decide for yourself!

        Interspecific hybrids, hybrids between 2 different species, are not regulated and have not been assessed for fertility status by the state of Oregon and are able to be sold:
        • 'Lilac Chip' butterfly bush with light purple flowers
          'Lilac Chip' interspecific hybrid. Photo courtesy Proven Winners, www.

          provenwinners.com

        • 'Miss Molly' butterfly bush with deep cranberry-hued flowers
          'Miss Molly' interspecific hybrid.  Photo courtesy Proven Winners, www.

          provenwinners.com

        • Deep pink flower spike and gray-green foliage of 'Miss Ruby' butterfly bush
          'Miss Ruby' interspecific hybrid. Photo courtesy Proven Winners, www.

          provenwinners.com

        • 'Miss Violet' butterfly bush with vibrant purple flower spikes
          'Miss Violet'  interspecific hybrid. Photo courtesy Proven Winners, www.

          provenwinners.com

        • Bright blue-purple flower spike of 'Purple Haze' butterfly bush contrasts beautifully with the chartreuse foliage behind it
          Buddleia Lo and Behold 'Purple Haze' approved by state of Oregon.  Photo courtesy Proven Winners, www.provenwinners.com
        • 'Lo and Behold' butterfly bush with tiger swallowtail visiting the lavender-blue flowers
          Buddleia Lo and Behold 'Blue Chip', approved by state of Oregon. Photo courtesy Proven Winners, www.

          provenwinners.com

        • Buddleia Low and Behold 'Blue Chip Jr.' massed in the garden
          Buddleia Lo and Behold 'Blue Chip Jr.', approved by state of Oregon. Photo courtesy Proven Winners, www.

          provenwinners.com

        • butterfly bush Lo and Behold 'Pink Micro Chip' as a tiny plant blooming heavily in the garden
          Buddleia Lo and Behold  'Pink Micro Chip', approved by state of Oregon. Photo courtesy Proven Winners, www.provenwinners.com
        • Row of white-blooming butterfly bushes Lo and Behold 'Ice Chip'
          Buddleia Lo and Behold 'Ice Chip', approved by state of Oregon. Photo courtesy Proven Winners, www.

          provenwinners.com

        • Deep purple flowers of butterfly bush 'Asian Moon' being visited by tiger swallowtail
          Buddleia 'Asian Moon', approved by state of Oregon. Photo courtesy Greenleaf Nursery, www.

          greenleafnursery.com

        • Creamy white flower of Vanilla Nectar Bush

          FLUTTERBY GRANDÉ™ Vanilla Nectar Bush, approved by state of Oregon. Photo courtesy Ball Horticulture, www.ballhort.com

        • Purple flower of Blueberry Cobbler Nectar Bush

          FLUTTERBY GRANDÉ™ Blueberry Cobbler Nectar Bush, approved by state of Oregon. Photo courtesy Ball Horticulture, www.ballhort.com

        • Peachy-pink flower cluster of Peach Cobbler Nectar Bush

          FLUTTERBY GRANDÉ™ Peach Cobbler Nectar Bush, approved by state of Oregon. Photo courtesy Ball Horticulture, www.ballhort.com

        • Orange flowers and gray-green foliage of Sweet Marmalade Nectar Bush

          FLUTTERBY GRANDÉ™ Sweet Marmalade Nectar Bush, approved by state of Oregon. Photo courtesy Ball Horticulture, www.ballhort.com

        • Bright orange flower cluster and silvery green foliage of Tangerine Dream Nectar Bush

          FLUTTERBY GRANDÉ™ Tangerine Dream Nectar Bush, approved by state of Oregon. Photo courtesy Ball Horticulture, www.ballhort.com

        • White flower cluster and silvery green foliage of Petite Snow White Nectar Bush

          FLUTTERBY GRANDÉ™ Petite Snow White Nectar Bush, approved by state of Oregon. Photo courtesy Greenleaf  Nursery, www.greenleafnursery.com

        • Butterfly Candy Lil Grape Buddleia in a grower pot
          Buddleia Butterfly Candy Lil Grape, Photo courtesy Ball Horticulture, www.ballhort.com
        • Heavily blooming pink flowers of Butterfly Candy Lil Taffy butterfly bush

          Buddleia Butterfly Candy Lil Taffy, Photo courtesy Ball Horticulture, www.ballhort.com

        • Large, bright magenta flower clusters on Butterfly Candy Lil Raspberry butterfly bush

          Buddleia Butterfly Candy Lil Raspberry, Photo courtesy Ball Horticulture, www.ballhort.com

        • Large white flower spikes cover a compact plant of Butterfly Candy Lil Coconut butterfly bush

          Buddleia Butterfly Candy Lil Coconut, Photo courtesy Ball Horticulture, www.ballhort.com

        You may also like

        Butterfly Gardening - Tips & Plants to Attract Butterflies
        It is easy to create or convert your garden into a private retreat for native butterflies. Butterflies use plants during each stage of their life cycle - egg, larva (caterpillar), pupa (chrysalis) and adult (butterfly). A butterfly garden that includes plants for the entire life cycle will attract the greatest number and variety of native [...]
        Not So Perennial Perennials
        Spring seemed to come late this year, with cool temperatures holding on in many areas of the country. Some of you let us know you still had snow in late April, and here in the Mid-Atlantic we’ve hardly had to turn on the air conditioning, as opposed to other years when we’ve had long [...]
        Plants for Japanese Garden Style
        Japanese style gardens emphasize simplicity and balance, incorporating a harmonious blend of trees, shrubs, grasses, and groundcovers with natural hardscaping materials. Depending on the size and style of your garden, plants may be few or may be a mixture of evergreens, deciduous trees or shrubs, and foliage perennials.  Kare Sansui, or Dry gardens will require only [...]